Afghan corruption tough to combat
By ROBERT H. REID and KATHY GANNON
Associated Press Writers
KABUL (AP) - President Hamid Karzai promised to stamp out
corruption. The image suggested otherwise. Standing at Karzai's
side on Tuesday were his two vice presidents - both former warlords
widely believed to have looted Afghanistan for years.
Reform is a tall order in a country awash in drug money. Afghans
pay bribes for everything from driver's licenses to police
protection, and the elite all too often treat state property as
their own.
``Right now 85 percent of the government is corrupt,'' said
Ahmed Shah Lumar, a businessman in the southern city of Kandahar.
He said bribery, extortion and other corrupt practices extend
``from the very small person'' in government to the very top.
International pressure is mounting on Karzai to make clean
government a top priority as he begins his second term after an
election marred by fraud. President Barack Obama wants concrete
steps, White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said Tuesday.
Gibbs told reporters that the U.S. Embassy in Kabul was working
with the Afghans on an anti-corruption compact, but he refused to
comment on specific benchmarks or deadlines.
``We're going to look for President Karzai to move boldly and
forcefully to initiate internal reforms,'' State Department
spokesman Ian Kelly said. ``And we stand ready to assist him in
that regard, to help him improve governance in Afghanistan, to
provide security for the Afghan people and provide the kind of
services that the people of Afghanistan deserve.''
In Kabul, Karzai acknowledged to reporters that Afghanistan
``has a bad name from corruption.'' He added, using a local
expression, that ``we will do our best through all possible means
to eliminate this dark stain from our clothes.''
Karzai said corruption could not be erased simply by replacing
certain officials. Instead, ``we need to review the law, where we
have problems,'' he said. One issue regarding the law has been a
failure to define bribery and other such practices.
The president also promised to strengthen a government
commission established a year ago to fight corruption.
``We ought to be skeptical about promises from Karzai with
respect to corruption,'' said Mark Moyar, professor of national
security affairs at U.S. Marine Corps University in Quantico, Va.
``He has promised to stamp out corruption on many previous
occasions, in response to pressure from Afghanistan's foreign
patrons, and has consistently failed to deliver.''
Even with a good faith effort, corruption is so deeply
entrenched in Afghan society that it could take decades to clean
up.
A March report by the U.S. Agency for International Development
found that corruption had reached ``an unprecedented scope in the
country's history.''
Corruption is not limited to the rich and powerful. It is woven
into the very fabric of everyday Afghan life.
Villagers in the southern province of Helmand say police
routinely stop them on the highways and demand money just to pass.
In the capital, Kabul, government employees shake down people
applying for driver's licenses, passports or building permits.
``If you have some work to be done, you need to get 30 people to
sign one piece of paper for you,'' said bank employee Safiullah
Habibi. ``Then you have to pay each person a small bribe to sign.''
The system feeds on itself. Several years ago, U.S. military
officials began hearing complaints that lower-ranking police
officers and soldiers never received their full salary. As the
money was transferred down the chain of command, officers and
sergeants would siphon off a portion for themselves.
Soldiers and police make up for the shortfall by stealing food
from merchants or shaking down motorists. U.S. Embassy and military
officials say the country's drug trade flourishes in part because
police take bribes to turn a blind eye to trafficking.
U.S. officials have since tried to institute an electronic
payment system to prevent commanders from taking cuts from
paychecks, but some soldiers still complain they do not receive all
they're owed.
``Even a judge in Afghanistan doesn't make enough money that he
can afford not to be corrupt,'' said Lumar, the Kandahar
businessman. ``From the judge to the policemen on the street, their
salaries are not enough to cover rent, hospital, education and
insurance for their families.''
Transparency International, a non-governmental organization,
last year ranked Afghanistan 176th out of 180 countries on its
corruption perceptions index, a poll that assesses the degree to
which corruption is perceived to exist among public officials and
politicians. Only Haiti, Iraq, Myanmar and Somalia were worse.
The police chief in Kandahar, Sadar Mohammad Zazai, acknowledges
corruption in his force but blames much of the problem on low
salaries, which start about $180 a month. A modest apartment goes
for about $80 a month, leaving little for food, clothing and other
expenses.
``There are a lot of problems that have to be addressed to deal
with corruption,'' he said.
Chief among them is the legacy of more than 30 years of war,
which all but destroyed state institutions. Many of the leaders who
played major roles in the country's internal conflicts remain in
power - including Karzai's two vice presidents, Mohammad Qasim
Fahim and Karim Khalili.
Earlier this year, the independent Afghanistan Rights Monitor
accused both of war crimes, charges they both deny. Karzai likely
put them on the ticket to win votes from their minority ethnic
communities. Many Afghans believe corruption can never be addressed
until the government breaks its ties to the warlords.
Nader Nadery of the Independent Human Rights Commission said
that to secure his re-election, Karzai likely made deals with
``some very bad names'' who now want key government positions for
their loyalists. He said Karzai will have to decide whether to make
good on such deals or ``deliver on the real promises (he) made to
the people and to the international community.''
Even with the best of intentions, Afghanistan's government
agencies established to fight corruption can barely cope.
A report issued in August by the U.S. Special Inspector
General's Office found that funding shortages and other problems
can undercut even well intentioned efforts to stem corruption and
the country's thriving drug trade.
At a cost of $11 million, Afghanistan's Counter-Narcotics
Justice Center opened in Kabul in May, three years behind schedule.
The center, which has already reached capacity, is the country's
only court for prosecuting major drug cases. Yet a lack of money
and the need to expand water, sewer and electrical utilities have
delayed plans to expand the center, making it difficult to
investigate and prosecute drug kingpins, according to the audit.
``Unfortunately corruption is endemic,'' Nadery said. ``It is at
so many layers that it paralyzes the government's ability to
provide services to the population.''
Reid reported from Kabul, Gannon from Kandahar. Associated Press
Writers Anne Gearan, Ben Feller, Matthew Lee, Lara Jakes and
Richard Lardner in Washington, Deb Riechmann, Heidi Vogt and Elena
Becatoros in Kabul, and Jason Straziuso in Nairobi, contributed to
this report.
11/03/09 17:30
© Copyright The Associated Press. All rights reserved. The information contained In this news report may not be published, broadcast or otherwise distributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press.